Ideas Match My Logic

How You Think Is the Game

Why we made a card game with no right answers.

By Cynthia and Jason Benjamin

Jason, Cynthia and two friends at a dinner table covered in Match My Logic cards.

Most of us believe we know the people we love. Mostly, we guess. Match My Logic lives in that gap.

The game

It began as Cynthia’s idea, one evening on our couch. One person puts five words in order. Everyone else tries to match their logic. Then the setter shows their order and explains it.

The explaining is the game. The best moments come from being wrong about someone you thought you knew, and finding out why.

No right answers

The cards that work best have no correct order. Nobody can look the answer up. You have to decide, and how you decide is yours.

We are careful about what the game is for. It doesn’t test what you know, and it doesn’t measure honesty. An order made in the moment isn’t a fact about you. It’s a glimpse of how you think right now, with these people, at this table.

Some people answer fast and trust it. Some go slow and build a case. Neither is better. It is a delight to find out which one the person across from you is.

Can a game show you how someone actually thinks?

Around a table

No one needs a screen to play it. That was always the point. A game draws a small circle with its own rules, and inside it people feel safe enough to show how they think.

What making it taught us

We took it from that couch through playtests, a Kickstarter, manufacturing and shipping. The morning the Kickstarter launched, our email service blocked us, so we wrote to people one by one. 267 people backed it. We hit our goal, and for a day it still felt like failing.

Months later an order came in from a stranger across the country. That one order felt like proof.

The game is on dining tables now, and on vacations, in towns we’ll never visit.

One round a day

There is now a daily round too. Rank five words. Find your match. It takes a minute, and it is the same game: see how you think, then see who thinks like you.

This Is Just the Beginning

Match My Logic is one of the first three things we have made. The idea behind all of them is larger than any one of them.